top of page
Search

On Audiobooks

Oct 6
6 min read

Updated: Oct 21

Okay, I have thoughts.


Okay, okay... if we have learned anything from the previous two blogs, I have forty-two separate trains of thought on audiobooks. Each is moving at a different speed in random directions and barely avoiding fatal crashes, purely because the train drivers are spawning their own thoughts and splitting into infinitesimally smaller trains each time.


I will try to limit the chaos of my many thoughts.


No promises.


Thought 1: Why do I find it so difficult to get into audiobooks? Who else is struggling?


I have tried to get into audiobooks for a while and it has just never really worked for me. Maybe it's the four children and the constant overuse of my ears listening to the increasingly urgent shouts of “Mom, Mom, Mooooommmm!” that makes listening to a book challenging for me.


I love reading and losing myself in a fictional story or grappling with different concepts in a nonfiction book.


But I just don't feel lost in an audiobook.


I refer again to the forty-two trains. When I am physically reading, actually feeling the paper against my fingertips and letting my eyes be guided across the page by the typed words, there is no room for more trains to go chugging along anywhere. It is a quiet and solitary pursuit which somehow creates a bubble of silence that even my four children's calls have to work a bit harder to break through.


When I start to play an audiobook, I don't feel the same sense of immersion. In fact, I still find my mind wandering off sometimes, and reeling that traveller back in can often feel impossible.


I have often said I don't understand why I enjoy podcasts but not audiobooks, and I think I am starting to understand why. Podcasts often repeat information. Granted, I am very much a true-crime podcast junkie, but that is a tale for another day. If I didn't register something the first time because my brain was off somewhere else, it almost doesn't matter. Chances are, the podcaster will repeat it, explain it again, or remind me of it later.


But a book? If you miss an element of a book, whether it's fiction or nonfiction, it can make parts further on in the book make less sense. I am sure there are other people out there who have experienced this. Actually, I really hope there are other people who have, so I can feel less alone in my inability to enjoy what is becoming an increasingly popular way to consume books.


Thought 2: Who picks the voices?


Seriously. WHO PICKS THE VOICES?


I have recently tried a few different recommendations — thanks, ChatGPT — based on which voices are becoming popular, and I found them instantly not for me. The books may have been brilliant, but I found the narrator's voice to be... let's endeavour to be polite and call it “not my cup of tea.”


I then found a rabbit hole into which I could lose myself, and literally a few hours of sleep, by asking for books read by a few actors whose voices I have found really capture my attention when I am doing my colour-by-number activities while watching a movie or TV show. This worked out slightly better, as I found I really enjoy Tom Hiddleston reading a book after dismissing a couple of others. Next I will try David Tennant and Alan Rickman, but this will of course become a limiting factor since most books are narrated by somebody who has been chosen by somebody else for whatever unknown reason.


Still, I do wonder who makes these choices and why? Which of course then begs the question:

Whose voice am I hearing when I actually read a physical book?


The answer: NOBODY'S.


When I read, I process the words, not a voice. Which, of course, explains why I absorb and retain more. And sadly, it also explains why, as much as I enjoyed Tom Hiddleston reading High-Rise by J.G. Ballard, I am not sure I remember much of the story.


I guess I'll find out when I try to listen again this evening...


Thought 3: Is listening to an audiobook really the same as reading the book?


I'm not really convinced for myself.


I see everyone starting to post their current progress on their reading goal for the year as we head into the final quarter, and I see many of them referring to audiobooks alongside physical books.


The Reading Olympics are a very competitive event that nobody is publicising or tracking on the news, which is a literary shame, so I am truly sorry if none of you have started seeing these posts on social media yet.


Seriously though, when people say, “I have read 372 books so far,” and then go on to talk about most of them being audiobooks, I find myself thinking:

How did you manage with all the annoying voices?

Followed quickly by:

But that's not reading.

And finished off with:

Why am I so judgemental?

Which, of course, is yet another story for another day.


I don't mean to judge. Okay, that's a lie. I absolutely cannot stop myself from judging. It's like a core skill.


But my passion for getting more people to read more often stems from the value I believe we get from translating the written word into a world in our mind, based on the pace and interpretation of the words.

When narrated, that image is influenced by the way in which the story is being told. If emphasis is placed on a word or a tone of voice changes, it's being “fed” to us, so to speak.


Edited and directed by somebody else's interpretation.


For me, it feels like the difference between a blank canvas and a photograph. One has infinite possibilities, while the other is framed based on the eye behind the camera. Which leads me to my next thought...


Thought 4: Audiobooks vs Movies/Series

Many readers will be somewhat opposed to watching a movie based on a book before they have read the book.


In case it was not clear, I am in this camp.


In fact, I will often reject a movie entirely as not being as good as the book. I am somewhat more open to a series based on a book if they do justice to the chapters sufficiently. I really do enjoy being lost in a world that exists entirely in my mind, which will be a completely different world when I read the same book years apart.


So why are readers more open to audiobooks than movies or series? The delivery is similar in terms of voice selection, direction of delivery, pace of storytelling and so on. Yes, I agree that the narrator reads every word and does not edit out chunks of the story to fit within a time limit. But there is definitely less left to the listener's imagination than when somebody is reading the words themselves.


I wonder: are there authors who are resisting the trend towards audiobooks?


Are there authors who are embracing it because it's another revenue stream?


Am I wrong about all of it and just being a purist who is unwilling to evolve?


If I am honest, I have an actual fear of a world without books. When Elon Musk started talking about a colony on Mars, my first concern was whether the atmosphere would be dangerous to books. I still haven't really given any further thought to any other possible impacts.


So my personal love of reading and books may be colouring my inability to get with the audiobook programme. But I do think there is something enjoyable about immersing yourself in the written word and emerging only occasionally to participate in the real world that I haven't really found to happen when I have tried audiobooks.


And maybe that's the thing.

Maybe audiobooks aren't supposed to replace reading.


Maybe they are simply another way of experiencing a story.


Maybe they work brilliantly for people whose brains don't have forty-two trains running in completely different directions.


And maybe one day I'll be one of those people. (If I'm being truthful, I hope not a lot of the time.)


But for now...

I'll keep reading.


What do you think?

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
On the Catalogue of Life

Thoughts and Meanderings Inspired by The Midnight Library and A Short Stay in Hell Yes, I admit it, I am the chaotic reader. The one who has 3 to 5 (or 11) books on the go at once. Why? Well, really,

 
 
 
Book Bans... What the what?

I've been seeing a lot of articles and posts about books being banned. This could be an artefact of my interest in libraries, bookshops and books, or perhaps I've read a few articles about book bans,

 
 
 
My brain answers life in song lyrics.

I have a problem. I don't know when it started, but increasingly, when something happens in my life, my brain responds with a song lyric. I sometimes weaponise this against my beloved husband.... he h

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page