top of page
Search

Book Bans... What the what?

Oct 15
5 min read

Updated: Oct 21

I've been seeing a lot of articles and posts about books being banned. This could be an artefact of my interest in libraries, bookshops and books, or perhaps I've read a few articles about book bans, which has prompted the algorithms that govern our access to information to show me more of the same. Regardless of why I'm seeing it, it's making me question a lot of things.


Firstly, when books are banned, what exactly are the people calling for the bans trying to achieve? Most of the supposedly offensive material will appear in other books. Perhaps not in the same concentration or combination of potentially offensive content, but the ideas will undoubtedly be covered elsewhere. More importantly, in the digital world, there are online resources that discuss these same concepts in forums, articles and support groups. It's unlikely that all the internet resources and other books will also be banned, so banning one particular book doesn't seem like a particularly effective strategy. It's a little bit like sweeping leaves in a tornado.


Of course, restricting access to a particular book can make it harder for people to read that specific title, especially in places where alternative sources aren't readily available. But restricting access to a book isn't the same as eliminating the ideas it contains. Those ideas can still find their way into other books, online discussions and conversations. So what, exactly, are they trying to achieve?


Secondly, are book-ban supporters really unaware that the more they push for something to be banned, the more likely it is that the book will be discussed, supported and publicised by people who oppose the ban? In the digital age, once a banning campaign makes it onto social media, people are likely to start discussing the book, actively seeking it out and campaigning against the ban.


Interestingly, research into book bans in the US has found that, in some cases, the publicity surrounding a ban actually increases circulation of the books being targeted. A 2025 study published in Marketing Science found that circulation of high-profile banned books increased by an average of 12% relative to comparable titles following a ban. The researchers also found increased circulation in states where the books had not been banned, with their analysis suggesting that children's readership increased too. So much for keeping the offending ideas out of circulation!


Thirdly, let's consider the lack of logic here. Book banners are using the widely protected right to freedom of speech, which many countries recognise, to prevent authors from exercising that same freedom to introduce different opinions and ideas. In doing so, they are attempting to restrict freedom of thought. Freedom of thought. Think about the Orwellian ideas in 1984. Book banners don't want you to read certain books because they want to prevent you from encountering ideas they believe you shouldn't have. Do people really believe that banning some books will prevent certain ideas from entering people's minds?


This reminds me of those moments when you wake up after a general anaesthetic and your mind is so discombobulated that you can't tell up from down. Or brain freeze. Whichever experience you can more readily draw on.


I remember a TV show from my childhood called AJ's Time Travellers. (Yes, this was early-'90s South Africa, when children's TV wasn't available 24 hours a day. You were literally limited to 15:00 to 17:00 on weekdays, if you were lucky.) Each episode had some sort of good-versus-evil storyline, but the main character would inevitably say, "SCIENTIA EST POTENTIA" at some point, which would result in a solution being found and good triumphing over evil.


What am I on about? Well, it translates to "Knowledge is Power", and that has always stuck with me. To me, reading has been many things: an escape, a way to relax, a distraction, therapy, a lifestyle and, most importantly, a lifelong quest for knowledge. Whether it's fiction or non-fiction, I've always believed there is something to be learned. Maybe it's different ways to approach situations. Or travelling into different lives. Or visiting other countries. Or understanding different life choices. Or experiencing challenges through the problems faced by others.


All that to say that when people feel they need to control what other people have access to, even if it's their own children, I begin to wonder why they feel it's their place to do so. What do they think will happen if their children are exposed to differing viewpoints? Is it a lack of belief in the values they've raised their children with? Is it that they believe different always means bad? Is it an unwillingness to evolve?


Having open and honest discussions with my own children (read that as debates in which they quote TikTok videos) has been one of the greatest amusements and privileges of being a parent. I know it's not everyone's cup of tea, but I love hearing their firm opinions, tightly held being challenged by the possibility that they might need to broaden their understanding. I believe that, as a parent, I need to help them open their minds, not tell them what they're allowed to consider when forming their opinions.


Aside from my perhaps rose-tinted view of raising children, I do wonder how this is still a thing in 2026. Why are we still struggling with such widespread small-mindedness? Maybe I'm being small-minded in my own views about banning books, but I have a fundamental issue with people trying to limit other people's access to knowledge and information. Surely all perspectives are worthy of frank and open discussion and debate? It's not about convincing other people to share your opinion, but rather about considering factors that may never have occurred to you. Isn't that the point of being able to speak your mind? (Hopefully in a respectful manner, obviously.)


I worry that the more book bans are publicised across the internet, the more people will come to believe that banning is a way to eradicate thoughts that don't align with their own. That because we don't agree with something, we should bury the idea so nobody can ever consider it.


I don't know which of my many childhood influences to credit for this belief, but I've long understood that rigorous debate with people who hold opposing views is a vital part of gaining knowledge and expanding my horizons. I know not everyone is a knowledge seeker, but shouldn't more people, at the very least, understand that all ideas and beliefs will be, and should be, challenged, if only to evolve and remain relevant?


Desmond Tutu once said, "Don't raise your voice, improve your argument" — advice he attributed to his own father. I think we need a similar one for book-ban proponents: "Don't ban books, broaden your understanding."


But that's just me. Standing with my broom in the middle of a tornado.


References:

  1. Book Bans in American Libraries: Impact of Politics on Inclusive Content Consumption, Ananthakrishnan et al., 2025, https://doi.org/10.1287/mksc.2024.0716

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
On the Catalogue of Life

Thoughts and Meanderings Inspired by The Midnight Library and A Short Stay in Hell Yes, I admit it, I am the chaotic reader. The one who has 3 to 5 (or 11) books on the go at once. Why? Well, really,

 
 
 
My brain answers life in song lyrics.

I have a problem. I don't know when it started, but increasingly, when something happens in my life, my brain responds with a song lyric. I sometimes weaponise this against my beloved husband.... he h

 
 
 
On Audiobooks

Okay, I have thoughts. Okay, okay... if we have learned anything from the previous two blogs, I have forty-two separate trains of thought on audiobooks. Each is moving at a different speed in random d

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page